Seton Hall vs. St. John’s Picks and Predictions: Unranked Big East Battle

The Big East is certainly having a weaker season overall, but they still produce exciting basketball! Tonight, we have two teams who were ranked at one point but are now on the outside looking in of the top 25 going head to head at Madison Square Garden. The Seton Hall Pirates face the St. John's Red Storm, as Shaheen Holloway and Rick Pitino lead their squads. Can the Johnnies cover another spread? Or will the Pirates beat St. John's for the first time in three contests? Let's dive into our expert CBB picks and find out how to wager on this matchup!

More NCAA Basketball Coverage

• Indiana vs. #3 Michigan
• #15 Vanderbilt vs. #20 Arkansas
• NC State vs. #18 Clemson
• DePaul vs. Butler
• #25 Miami (OH) vs. Kent State

Best Bet: Adam Clark Over 4.5 Assists (+160) Lucky Rebel Sportsbook

1

4.9/5 Review Rating

Bonus & Benefits
Up to $1,250 + 50 Free Slots Spins
See our review »

$1,250 Welcome Bonus
Bet Live on Your Favorite Sports
Earn More with Rebel Rewards!

Play Now & Claim Bonus »

Go check out what else I've got on my daily card, and view the latest odds at the best online sportsbooks.

Seton Hall Pirates vs. St. John's Red Storm NCAA Basketball Insights

Zuby Ejiofer and St. John's look to extend their winning streak tonight at Madison Square Garden

St. John's was ranked No. 5 to start this season, but quickly fell off. They lost their first three ranked matchups to No. 15 Alabama, to No. 15 Iowa State and then to No. 21 Auburn, all on neutral sites, although they lost to the Crimson Tide at Madison Square Garden. However, they have turned the page and are playing great basketball recently. St. John's is 6-1 in Big East play, losing only to Providence but bouncing back by winning four straight. Can they add another tonight?

Seton Hall is 14-4 on the season but just 4-3 in Big East play. Their only non conference loss was to the USC Trojans in the Maui Invitational Semifinals, beating Washington State to take third place. They lost to Villanova, won three straight, but now bring a two game losing streak into this matchup, having dropped contests to No. 3 UConn and Butler. However, I still have faith in this basketball team, and I thoroughly enjoy their style of play.

Matchup Information – Seton Hall vs. St. John's – January 20

• Venue & Location: Madison Square Garden (New York, NY)
• Date: Tuesday, January 20, 2025
• Kick Off: 7:00 p.m. Eastern
• Broadcast: FS1

Seton Hall vs. St. John's Betting Odds

Odds are courtesy of Lucky Rebel, one of our favorite online sportsbooks, as of January 20, 2025 at 10:39 a.m. eastern. Sign up today with and get a $1,250 deposit bonus, as well as 50 slot spins immediately. Lucky Rebel Sportsbook offers a wide variety of unique markets across nearly every sport imaginable.

Spread

• Seton Hall +11 (-114)
• St. John's -11 (-106)

Moneyline

• Seton Hall +435
• St. John's -625

Total

• Over 145.5 (-113)
• Under 145.5 (-107)

St. John's is incredibly fast, while Seton Hall is significantly slower. I expect the Johnnies to turn up the tempo, forcing the Pirates to defend longer and more often, however that will also give Seton Hall's offense more chances as well. Which leads me to my favorite player prop in this game.

Seton Hall vs. St. John's NCAA Basketball Picks and Predictions

Budd Clark averages 4.7 assists for the Pirates so far this year, clearing this line in half of his games

Seton Hall vs. St. John's Prediction: St. John's Wins, Seton Hall Covers, Over 145.5

Best Bet: Adam Clark Over 4.5 Assists (+160) Lucky Rebel Sportsbook

Adam "Budd" Clark was a stud for the Merrimack Warriors last year, and now he is showing out on the Power Five level. He leads the Pirates with 4.7 assists per game, after averaging 3.9 and 6.0 in two seasons with Merrimack. Clark is a true point guard who looks to set up his teammates, and he's done a great job of doing so this season.

Sure, the Johnnies are a very good defensive team, but if you give Clark enough opportunities, he's going to find a way to get the ball to his teammates in a scoring position. He has started every game for the Pirates and leads the team in minutes, averaging 28.2, the only player to play more than 25 per game. Point being, he is always on the floor.

Now, his original line is 3.5 for -130, but I opted to take it up an assist for a bigger reward. If he ends with four, so be it, that's the risk we are taking. He's had 5+ assists in 9/18 games this year (4+ in 10/18) ending with seven in four separate games, and having as many as 12. In eight games where he has played 30+ minutes, he's cleared this line in six of those contests.

It's been four games since he's gotten over this number, but tonight against a very good St. John's team, Holloway is going to need him on the court, and I'm confident in Clark being able to create chances for his teammates.

Still Didn't Get Your NCAA Basketball Fix?

Here at Betting News, we offer Free Expert Picks for every major sports league. We also host daily streams on our Twitch Channel with our best bets, as well as sweat out games on Playback! Be sure to tune into everything we have going on at our Youtube, TikTok, and X pages as well, and follow my personal twitter @Shaggy_Bets for my full daily card.

• Transfer Portal Update
• 2025-2026 NCAA Basketball Preview
• SEC Basketball Preview
• Big 12 Conference Picks
• Big Ten Conference Predictions
• ACC Basketball Preview

More NCAAB News

NCAAB Betting News

NCAA Expands March Madness Tournament to 76 Teams Beginning in 2027

Nate Hornung Wed Apr 29 2026

NCAAB Betting News

NCAA Basketball Transfer Portal Update: Portal Entries and New Signings

Nate Hornung Fri Apr 10 2026

NCAAB Betting News

NCAA Basketball Coaching Changes: Where Are They Now?

Nate Hornung Thu Apr 9 2026

NCAAB Betting News

#2 UConn vs. #1 Michigan Picks and Predictions: National Championship

Nate Hornung Mon Apr 6 2026

Check Out All of Our Betting Resources at Betting News