Red Sox vs. Yankees Game 1: Hitter Props | September 30, 2025
Written by: Colby Marchio
Published: Tue Sep 30, 2025, 2:53 pm ET
Read Time: 4 minutes
mlb
Game 1: The stage shifts to the Bronx for game one of this AL Wild Card clash between the Red Sox and Yankees. All eyes are on Boston ace Garret Crochet, who has carved up lineups down the stretch and looks like the kind of arm who can flip a series on his own.
The betting markets expect him to dominate again, especially against a Yankee team he has handled recently. But postseason baseball has a way of turning stars into legends, and New York's power bats are built for moments like this. Tonight, I see real value leaning on the Yankees.
For additional information on picks, props, moneylines, and more on today's slate, take a look at our MLB Picks Page or our MLB Odds Page, here.
Write Up Transparency
Be sure to follow me on X/Twitter @ColbyMBets to get my full card every day! Picks are always FREE.
Last Month: 29-82 (-22.27u)
Last Week: 9-17 (-4.24u)
ICE COLD. FADE ME.
Red Sox vs. Yankees Game 1 Best Bets – September 30
Do the Yankees stand a chance against the Red Sox in Game 1?
Check out BetOnline's New No Strings Welcome Offer that gives new MLB players up to $250 in Free Bets and 100 Free Casino Spins with their first deposit. Find out more about this Promotion as well as lots of other Free Sportsbook Promos right here!
We head to the Bronx for the third game of the day as the Red Sox and Yankees square off in game one of this AL Wild Card Series. Boston ace Garret Crochet gets the ball, and many will write off New York based on his recent dominance against them.
That is exactly why I see value. With the books pricing this as another shove spot for the left-hander, there is opportunity to back two of the hottest bats in the game, both sitting right in the Yankees lineup.
Back the Big Bats
Aaron Judge over 1.5 bases at plus money is an auto-play, while Giancarlo Stanton simply to record a hit at $1.35 is too good to ignore. Judge is on a generational heater, batting well above .300 the past month with absurd power numbers. Stanton, while quieter, has put together a steady September, hitting .224 with a .641 SLG and 1.011 OPS. I only need the floor from him here, just one knock.
Both mash against lefties and their Batters-Box elite ratings back it up. Judge, across 316 elite-rated spots, records a hit 69% of the time, goes for 2+ hits 32%, homers 30%, and clears 1.5 bases 50%. At home, that last number jumps to 53%. Stanton, in 112 elite ratings, records a hit 63% overall and 71% at home.
Yes, Crochet has looked dominant, but the deeper numbers tell another story. Against his last 60 right-handed hitters, opponents own a .339 xBA and .675 xSLG. On the season, he is allowing 41% hard contact. Judge and Stanton specialize in hard contact, and tonight sets up perfectly for both to cash.
At the end of the day, the books are banking on Crochet to keep rolling, but the matchup numbers tell a different story. Judge and Stanton are not only in rhythm, they are positioned perfectly to take advantage of Crochet's recent struggles against right-handed hitters. With Judge in the middle of a historic run and Stanton delivering consistent power all September, I see both as strong value plays tonight. Sometimes you bet against the trends, and sometimes you lean into them. Tonight, I am leaning heavily on the Yankees' two biggest bats to deliver in the Bronx.
Best Bet: Aaron Judge Over 1.5 Bases (+110) & Giancarlo Stanton 1+ Hit (-135) BetOnline
Interested in More Content?
Get FREE Picks and Props Weekly
Sign up for
THE WEEKENDER NEWSLETTER
Follow me on X @ColbyMBets for all my picks and sports opinions. Follow Betting News on 'X' and Twitch and catch us on stream! Betting News is also on TikTok! Follow us for more picks and news every day!
In need of a sportsbook? Check out one of our favorites below among our best online sportsbooks and sign-up for a bonus!
Check Out All of Our Betting Resources at Betting News
- Picks & Odds for the NFL
- NFL Betting Guide for Beginners
- Pick & Odds for NCAAF
- NCAAF Betting Guide for Beginners
- Picks & Odds in the MLB
- MLB Betting Guide for Beginners
- Picks & Odds in the NBA
- NBA Betting Guide for Beginners
- Picks & Odds in the NHL
- NHL Betting Guide for Beginners
More Betting Stories
Former D1 (club) baseball player, Colby has been betting since his college days at DePaul, where he had to endure the worst collegiate basketball the Big East has ever seen. He is an advanced analytics nerd and has never seen an underdog he has not liked. Hot. Corn. Bull. It does not matter the dog he loves them all.
This site contains commercial content. We may be compensated for the links provided on this page. The content on this page is for informational purposes only. Betting News makes no representation or warranty as to the accuracy of the information given or the outcome of any game or event.
More MLB News
MLB Betting News
(6/9) MLB | The Daily Dinger Report — Dinger Tuesday
Varun Sharma