Toronto Blue Jays vs New York Yankees Picks, Odds & Player Props

MLB - FINAL

@ Yankee Stadium, Bronx

Toronto Blue Jays logo
FINAL
New York Yankees logo

Toronto Blue Jays
2

New York Yankees
1

Best Odds

Toronto Blue Jays vs. New York Yankees MLB Picks and Predictions: May 20, 2026

Toronto Blue Jays vs. New York Yankees MLB Picks and Predictions: May 20, 2026 - Nate Hornung

Consensus Picks

New! Want sharper MLB picks today? Our free BN Prediction Engine breaks down every matchup before first pitch to calculate win probability and project the likely winner. Whether you're hunting a strong edge or just validating your read on tonight's game, this is the fastest way to turn MLB betting predictions into confident decisions.

BN Prediction Engine

FINAL

Projected Winner

New York Yankeesto win
Confidence66.72%(Strong edge)
Rating edgeStrong edge
Toronto Blue Jays logo

Toronto Blue Jays

33.3%

BN Fair Odds

+200

Starting Pitcher

Trey Yesavage

New York Yankees logo

New York Yankees

66.7%

BN Fair Odds

-200

Starting Pitcher

Cam Schlittler

Team Ratings

TOR (Away)vsNYY (Home)

Strong82

Pitcher

Strong86
Above Avg62

Bullpen

Above Avg61
Below Avg33

Defense

Strong78
Below Avg31

Offense

Above Avg69
Weak (0–25)
Below Avg (25–40)
Average (40–55)
Above Avg (55–70)
Strong (70+)

Projection is based on current pitcher, bullpen, defense and offense ratings. Ratings are percentile-based from 0–100.

Betting Records

TOR

TOR

NYY

NYY

22 - 27(21st)

9 - 16

Wins

Away/Home

(6th)29 - 20

16 - 7

23 - 26 - 0(17th)

11 - 14 - 0

ATS

Away/Home

(13th)25 - 24 - 0

13 - 10 - 0

23 - 22 - 4(25th)

11 - 11 - 3

Ov / Un

Away/Home

(24th)23 - 17 - 9

13 - 6 - 4

Batting Stats

TOR

TOR

NYY

NYY
3.92
Runs / Game
4.65
0.430
Stolen Bases / Game
0.940
0.980
Home Runs / Game
1.440
0.243
Batting Average
0.234
0.682
On Base %
0.730
0.379
Slugging %
0.417
1.060
OBPS
1.150

Fielding Stats

TOR

TOR

NYY

NYY
0.65
Errors / Game
0.57
0.982
Fielding %
0.984

Pitching Stats

TOR

TOR

NYY

NYY
0.242
Batting Average Against
0.225
0.386
Slugging % Against
0.363
0.977
On Base % Against
0.975
0.266
Strike Out %
0.268
0.640
Strike %
0.642
0.360
Ball %
0.358

Last 5 Games

TORTOR

Result

ATS

Total

@ NYY

W2 - 1

W+1.5

7

@ NYY

L4 - 5

W+1.5

8

@ NYY

L6 - 7

W+1.5

9

@ DET

W4 - 1

W-1.5

8

@ DET

W2 - 1

W+1.5

8

NYYNYY

Result

ATS

Total

vs TOR

L2 - 1

L-1.5

7

vs TOR

W4 - 5

L-1.5

8

vs TOR

W6 - 7

L-1.5

9

@ NYM

L6 - 7

L-1.5

8

@ NYM

L3 - 6

L-1.5

P9

More MLB Articles