NHL Most Fights Odds: Olivier Leads 2026-27 Market
Written by: Jonathan Rodriguez
Published: Wed Sep 23, 2026, 10:00 am ET
Read Time: 6 minutes
Misc.
The 2026-27 NHL regular season is approaching, bringing another campaign of physical hockey. BetOnline has posted odds on which player will record the most fights.
Mathieu Olivier leads the market at 2/1, while Mark Kastelic and Curtis Douglas follow at 7/2. Ross Johnston and Tanner Jeannot round out the top five at 5/1.
Last season's numbers provide useful context for the market. Kastelic and Douglas tied for the NHL lead with 10 fights each in 2025-26. Johnston and Olivier followed with nine apiece.
The prices also show how closely grouped the leading candidates are. Olivier's 2/1 price carries an implied probability of 33.3% before accounting for the sportsbook's margin. At 16/1, Matt Rempe's implied probability falls to 5.9%.
NHL Most Fights Odds Leaderboard
Player
Odds
Mathieu Olivier
2/1
Mark Kastelic
7/2
Curtis Douglas
7/2
Ross Johnston
5/1
Tanner Jeannot
5/1
Arber Xhekaj
6/1
Brandon Duhaime
15/2
Sam Carrick
10/1
Tyler Tucker
10/1
A.J. Greer
10/1
Bettors comparing NHL markets across US online sportsbooks can track how the most-fights odds shift before the season begins.
Mathieu Olivier (2/1):The 33.3% Market Favorite
Olivier enters as the shortest-priced player in the market after recording nine fights last season.
His 2025-26 schedule included several established heavyweights. He fought Curtis Douglas, Sam Carrick, Ryan Reaves, Kurtis MacDermid and Mark Kastelic.
Those matchups show how often Olivier finds himself in games featuring willing combatants. His fight history also gives him a strong baseline for another high total.
At 2/1, BetOnline's price implies a 33.3% probability before the sportsbook's margin.
Mark Kastelic (7/2): The 10-Fight Benchmark
Kastelic has the strongest recent statistical case among the leading candidates. He tied Douglas for the NHL lead with 10 fights during 2025-26.
His opponents included Logan O'Brien, Moritz Seider, Luke Schenn and Kurtis MacDermid. He also fought Olivier late in the season.
That experience against other physical players makes Kastelic a natural contender. His 7/2 price implies a 22.2% probability before accounting for the margin.
Curtis Douglas (7/2): The 10-Fight Threat
Douglas also reached 10 fights last season, matching Kastelic for the league lead.
He fought several notable heavyweights, including MacDermid, Olivier, Tom Wilson and Nicolas Deslauriers.
Douglas moved through Tampa Bay and Vancouver during the 2025-26 season. He then signed a two-year contract with Seattle in July 2026.
His new situation gives him a clearer NHL contract path entering 2026-27. Still, his fight total will depend on how consistently Seattle keeps him in the lineup.
Ross Johnston (5/1): Nine Fights Keep Him Close
Johnston recorded nine fights last season, putting him just one behind the league-leading total. His fight card included matchups against Ryan Reaves, Tanner Jeannot, A.J. Greer and Luke Schenn. In the upcoming season, Johnston will be playing for the St. Louis Blues. He'll bring his size, strength, and intimidation factor to wear down opposing defensemen.
The Jeannot matchup stands out because both players appear among BetOnline's five shortest prices. Johnston's previous fight volume therefore gives his 5/1 price a clear statistical foundation.
That price translates to a 16.7% implied probability before the sportsbook's margin.
Tanner Jeannot (5/1): A Proven Physical Matchup
Jeannot recorded eight fights during the 2025-26 campaign.
He also fought Johnston on October 23, creating a direct matchup between two players near the top of this market. Jeannot also faced MacDermid during the season.
His eight-fight total trails the leading group, but his willingness to engage keeps him among the main contenders.
At 5/1, Jeannot carries the same 16.7% raw implied probability as Johnston.
Other NHL Most Fights Contenders
Arber Xhekaj sits at 6/1 after recording eight fights last season. Brandon Duhaime follows at 15/2 after also finishing with eight.
Duhaime enters 2026-27 with Toronto after signing a three-year contract with the Maple Leafs. Sam Carrick, meanwhile, moved to Buffalo after the Sabres acquired him from the Rangers in March 2026.
Carrick recorded nine fights last season, making his 10/1 price notable despite sitting outside the top five. Tyler Tucker and A.J. Greer also sit at 10/1.
Tom Wilson is priced at 12/1, while Matt Rempe follows at 16/1. Michael McCarron has the longest price at 18/1.
Matt Rempe (16/1): High Profile, Limited Opportunities
Rempe's reputation makes him one of the most recognizable names in the market. However, his fight total still depends on how much he plays.
Game misconducts can remove him from games, while limited ice time reduces the number of situations where a fight can occur. Those restrictions can directly cap his total bout opportunities.
His 16/1 price therefore reflects a much lower implied probability of 5.9% before the sportsbook's margin.
How Fights Could Shape the 2026-27 NHL Season
Fighting remains part of the NHL's physical identity, although opportunities vary considerably by player and team.
A fight can change the energy inside a game, particularly when teams are battling for momentum. However, penalties and game misconducts can also remove players from the action.
That makes regular ice time an important factor in this market. Players need enough opportunities to reach the top of the fight leaderboard.
Last season's totals highlight the importance of that opportunity. Kastelic and Douglas each recorded 10 fights, while Johnston and Olivier finished with nine.
Check the Latest NHL Odds
The most-fights market will change as teams finalize rosters and the 2026-27 regular season approaches.
For updated NHL odds and other hockey betting markets, check BetOnline throughout the season.
Miscellaneous Sports Miscellaneous Sports Miscellaneous Sports Miscellaneous SportsMore Miscellaneous Sports News
AI Czar Odds: Who Could Trump Pick Next?
2026 MLB World Series Odds: Dodgers Lead as Rays Surge
NFL Retirement Odds: 10 Veterans Facing Career Decisions
MLB Expansion Team Odds: Which Cities Have the Best Chance?
Jonathan Rodriguez
Jonathan is an avid basketball fan, and is often looking forward to the next upcoming NBA season when not checking players' stats during games. He also likes to keep his ears on the ground for the latest rumblings in the online casino industry.
This site contains commercial content. We may be compensated for the links provided on this page. The content on this page is for informational purposes only. Betting News makes no representation or warranty as to the accuracy of the information given or the outcome of any game or event.