Second Circuit Rejects Kalshi and Coinbase Injunctions

Jonathan Rodriguez

Written by: Jonathan Rodriguez

Published: Wed Nov 04, 2026, 8:00 am ET

Read Time: 6 minutes

Second Circuit Rejects Kalshi and Coinbase Injunctions

industry

Kalshi and Coinbase have suffered another legal setback after the Second Circuit denied their emergency injunction requests. 

The decision allows New York and Connecticut to continue pursuing enforcement against sports event contracts. However, the companies' underlying appeals remain unresolved.

The November 3 ruling followed oral arguments before a three-judge appellate panel. Judges John M. Walker Jr., Joseph F. Bianco, and Dennis Jacobs heard arguments from the companies, the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), and state representatives. 

The court issued its denial immediately following the arguments, declining to grant the companies temporary protection while their appeals proceed.

The order stated: "Upon due consideration, it is hereby ORDERED that the motions are DENIED because Appellants have failed to make the required showing that an injunction pending appeal is warranted."

This decision does not settle whether the Commodity Exchange Act (CEA) preempts state gambling laws. Instead, it allows both states to continue challenging Kalshi's sports event contracts through their respective legal proceedings.

Second Circuit Judges Question Federal Protection for Sports Contracts

The Second Circuit's decision followed arguments from Kalshi, Coinbase, the CFTC, and representatives of New York and Connecticut.

The appeals involved three separate cases: Kalshi's disputes with New York and Connecticut, alongside Coinbase Financial Markets' Connecticut lawsuit. This distinction matters because Coinbase does not operate the exchange listing the contracts.

Coinbase Financial Markets is a CFTC-registered futures commission merchant (FCM). It acts as an intermediary, providing customers access to event contracts listed on Kalshi's designated contract market (DCM). Coinbase began offering Kalshi's event contracts, including sports markets, through its platform in January 2026.

During the hearing, the judges questioned whether sports event contracts satisfy the CEA's statutory definition of swaps. Kalshi maintains that its contracts fall under federal commodities regulation rather than state gambling oversight.

However, the judges expressed reservations about extending federal derivatives regulation to conventional sports betting products. Coinbase also argued that the CEA does not specifically exclude sports-related contracts from federal oversight.

The companies' position could have significant implications for US online sportsbooks and prediction market operators. If sports event contracts receive federal protection, states could face greater restrictions when regulating these products. 

Conversely, an unfavorable ruling could strengthen state authority over sports-related prediction markets.

New York Previously Rejected Kalshi's Federal Preemption Argument

Kalshi filed for an injunction in New York earlier this year. However, U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Judge Analisa Torres denied the motion in July.

Torres disagreed with Kalshi's assertion that the CEA preempts state gambling laws. She determined that New York could apply its gambling regulations to the operator's sports event contracts.

"The Court finds that New York gambling laws as applied to Kalshi's sports event contracts are not preempted by the CEA and Kalshi has not, therefore, made a clear or substantial showing that it is likely to succeed on the merits," Torres wrote in her decision.

New York's enforcement action alleges that Kalshi operated an unauthorized gambling business. The state is pursuing financial penalties and other remedies against the prediction market operator.

The latest appellate decision removes another potential obstacle to those enforcement efforts. Consequently, Kalshi cannot rely on an emergency injunction to prevent New York from pursuing its case while the appeal continues.

Connecticut Judge Also Rejected Kalshi's and Coinbase's CEA Arguments

Connecticut secured a similar legal victory after U.S. District Judge Vernon D. Oliver rejected preliminary injunction requests from Kalshi and Coinbase Financial Markets in August.

Oliver concluded that Kalshi's sports event contracts did not satisfy the statutory definition of swaps under the CEA. His reasoning focused on the distinction between sporting events themselves and their outcomes.

"Kalshi's sports-event contracts fail to satisfy this portion of the statutory definition of a swap because they do not depend on whether an underlying sporting event occurs, fails to occur, or occurs to a particular extent. Instead, Kalshi's sports-event contracts depend on the event's outcomes or discrete in-game occurrences. Treating those outcomes as separate 'events' would depart from the ordinary meaning of the term. Thus, Kalshi's sports-event contracts do not fall within § 1a(47)(A)(ii)," Oliver wrote in his decision.

Coinbase advanced essentially the same federal preemption argument. It maintained that Connecticut could not apply its gambling regulations to Kalshi contracts offered through Coinbase's platform. However, Oliver found that Coinbase had not established a likelihood of success on its claims.

CFTC Issues Emergency Order for Kalshi

Following Oliver's ruling, the CFTC issued an emergency order supporting Kalshi's continued operations under federal exchange requirements. The regulator's intervention sought to reinforce federal oversight amid the growing dispute with state authorities.

Kalshi subsequently attempted to use the CFTC's order to secure additional protection from enforcement. Oliver rejected that argument on August 17, finding that the regulator's intervention did not justify overturning his earlier decision.

The companies then pursued their arguments before the Second Circuit, seeking injunctions while their appeals remained pending. The appellate court's November 3 denial now leaves Connecticut free to continue its enforcement efforts.

Connecticut Attorney General William Tong also defended the state's enforcement position. He argued that prediction market contracts resemble traditional sports betting and should follow state consumer protection requirements.

"Sports event contracts are no different than sports betting and are not magically shielded by federal law from Connecticut's commonsense consumer protection laws. These laws exist for a reason – to protect minors, to prevent problem gambling, to ensure your money is safe and your personal information is protected. None of that is happening now on Kalshi, and we're suing to put a stop to it," Tong said in the state's announcement.

The dispute therefore extends beyond regulatory jurisdiction. Lawmakers maintain that Connecticut gambling laws protect consumers from potential financial and personal information risks.

Conflicting Federal Appeals Court Rulings Complicate Prediction Market Regulation

The Second Circuit's decision adds another development to an increasingly divided national legal landscape. Federal appeals courts have reached different conclusions about whether the CEA preempts state gambling laws.

In April 2026, the Third Circuit ruled in Kalshi's favor in its dispute with New Jersey. The court concluded that Kalshi's sports event contracts qualified as swaps under the CEA. It also found that federal law prevented New Jersey from enforcing its gambling regulations against those contracts.

However, the Ninth Circuit reached the opposite conclusion in August. Its ruling against Kalshi upheld a decision allowing state gambling restrictions to apply to sports event contracts. The court found that those contracts did not qualify as swaps under the CEA.

Illinois has also become another important battleground. In October, a federal district court granted parts of preliminary injunction requests involving Coinbase, Kalshi, and the CFTC. However, it continued other aspects of the proceedings, leaving important questions unresolved.

These developments highlight the growing conflict between federal commodities oversight and state gambling regulation. They also increase the likelihood of further appeals and potential Supreme Court involvement.

State Enforcement Continues as Prediction Market Appeals Remain Pending

The Second Circuit's decision allows New York and Connecticut to continue their respective enforcement efforts. However, it does not represent a final ruling on whether Kalshi's sports event contracts violate state gambling laws.

The underlying appeals could still determine how federal commodities legislation applies to prediction markets. They could also establish clearer boundaries between CFTC oversight and state gambling regulation.

For Kalshi and Coinbase, the latest decision means they must continue defending their federal preemption arguments without the requested appellate protection. Meanwhile, both states can advance their cases against the companies.

The outcome could influence other jurisdictions considering restrictions on sports event contracts. It may also affect how prediction markets compete with licensed US online sportsbooks.

Ultimately, the Second Circuit's eventual ruling on the underlying appeals remains crucial. Until then, the legal battle between federal regulators and state gambling authorities will continue shaping the US prediction markets industry.

Jonathan Rodriguez
Jonathan Rodriguez

Jonathan is an avid basketball fan, and is often looking forward to the next upcoming NBA season when not checking players' stats during games. He also likes to keep his ears on the ground for the latest rumblings in the online casino industry.

This site contains commercial content. We may be compensated for the links provided on this page. The content on this page is for informational purposes only. Betting News makes no representation or warranty as to the accuracy of the information given or the outcome of any game or event.